The Berean Codex™Scripture Research Project
Research library · Reception history · Dependency analysis

Dependency profile — Strong Catholic formulation — Peter receives a divinely instituted primacy perpetuated in the Roman pontiffs

A reusable research record with provenance and relationships kept separate from the presentation layer.

INTERPRETATION_DEPENDENCY_PROFILEDEP_INT_MAT_16_CATHOLIC_FORMULATION
Interpretation Dependency Profile

Reception History Only

Profiled target: Strong Catholic formulation — Peter receives a divinely instituted primacy perpetuated in the Roman pontiffs

Argument-dependency analysis for the Matthew 16 doctrine stress test. The profile cannot increase evidentiary weight.

Premises

Reception Application · Reception Only · Documentation

Vatican I explicitly formulates the Petrine → perpetual successor → Roman pontiff → universal jurisdiction chain.

Premise P1

Traditional Authority Premise · Rejected As Authority Shortcut · Rejected

Vatican I’s authority by itself proves every exegetical premise.

Premise P2

Dependency chain

Vatican I explicitly formulates the Petrine → perpetual successor → Roman pontiff → universal jurisdiction chain.
Vatican I’s authority by itself proves every exegetical premise.

Curated chronology

State: HISTORICAL_ORIGIN_UNKNOWN

Date Label: v57 curated corpus

Date Sort Key: 9999

Note: This profile distinguishes the current Archive evidence chain from historical origin. The earliest loaded witness is not a claim that the idea originated there.

Not an origin claim: this records the earliest currently curated witness relevant to the profile, not the first historical occurrence.

Development threads: THREAD_MAT_16_PETRINE_TO_PAPAL_CHAIN, THREAD_MAT_16_ROCK_RECEPTION_DIVERSITY

What this profile does not establish

That Vatican I is simply “what Matthew says.”
That Catholic doctrine lacks any argument beyond Matthew 16.
That later definition equals historical origin.

What this does not establish

That Vatican I is simply “what Matthew says.”
That Catholic doctrine lacks any argument beyond Matthew 16.
That later definition equals historical origin.
Release Introduced
v57
Passage Id
PASSAGE_MAT_16_13_20
Status
CURATED_PUBLIC