INTERPRETATION_DEPENDENCY_PROFILE
DEP_INT_MAT_16_PATRISTIC_DIVERSITYReception History Only
Profiled target: Early patristic reception is materially diverse and cannot be reduced to a single later denominational formula
Argument-dependency analysis for the Matthew 16 doctrine stress test. The profile cannot increase evidentiary weight.
Premises
Reception Application · Reception Only · Documentation
The curated patristic sources document materially different emphases.
Premise P1
Traditional Authority Premise · Rejected As Authority Shortcut · Rejected
Counting or antiquity of fathers decides original meaning.
Premise P2
Dependency chain
The curated patristic sources document materially different emphases.
Counting or antiquity of fathers decides original meaning.
Curated chronology
State: HISTORICAL_ORIGIN_UNKNOWN
Date Label: v57 curated corpus
Date Sort Key: 9999
Note: This profile distinguishes the current Archive evidence chain from historical origin. The earliest loaded witness is not a claim that the idea originated there.
Not an origin claim: this records the earliest currently curated witness relevant to the profile, not the first historical occurrence.
Development threads: THREAD_MAT_16_PETRINE_TO_PAPAL_CHAIN, THREAD_MAT_16_ROCK_RECEPTION_DIVERSITY
What this profile does not establish
That these are the only patristic readings.
That the earliest loaded record is the historical origin of a view.
That majority counting among selected fathers determines Matthew’s meaning.
What this does not establish
That these are the only patristic readings.
That the earliest loaded record is the historical origin of a view.
That majority counting among selected fathers determines Matthew’s meaning.
- Release Introduced
- v57
- Passage Id
- PASSAGE_MAT_16_13_20
- Status
- CURATED_PUBLIC