INTERPRETATION_DEPENDENCY_PROFILE
DEP_INT_MAT_16_ROMAN_JURISDICTIONContext Model Dependent
Profiled target: Roman Petrine succession does not by itself establish universal jurisdiction over all bishops
Argument-dependency analysis for the Matthew 16 doctrine stress test. The profile cannot increase evidentiary weight.
Premises
Later Doctrinal Premise · Disputed · Prerequisite
The bishop of Rome uniquely succeeds to Peter’s Petrine office.
Premise P1
Later Doctrinal Premise · Disputed · Core Bridge
That succession entails jurisdiction over every bishop and local church.
Premise P2
Dependency chain
The bishop of Rome uniquely succeeds to Peter’s Petrine office.
That succession entails jurisdiction over every bishop and local church.
Curated chronology
State: HISTORICAL_ORIGIN_UNKNOWN
Date Label: v57 curated corpus
Date Sort Key: 9999
Note: This profile distinguishes the current Archive evidence chain from historical origin. The earliest loaded witness is not a claim that the idea originated there.
Not an origin claim: this records the earliest currently curated witness relevant to the profile, not the first historical occurrence.
Development threads: THREAD_MAT_16_PETRINE_TO_PAPAL_CHAIN, THREAD_MAT_16_ROCK_RECEPTION_DIVERSITY
What this profile does not establish
That Catholic universal jurisdiction is disproved merely because it is doctrinally developed.
That all Orthodox churches formulate primacy identically to Moscow.
What this does not establish
That Catholic universal jurisdiction is disproved merely because it is doctrinally developed.
That all Orthodox churches formulate primacy identically to Moscow.
- Release Introduced
- v57
- Passage Id
- PASSAGE_MAT_16_13_20
- Status
- CURATED_PUBLIC